This is a very confusing post because, first of all, I have no idea why it is called "Our pets in heaven." Do you believe that animals have an eternal soul?
![Huh ???](http://www.creationliberty.com/forum/Smileys/aaron/huh.gif)
If so, would you give your Scriptural backing to that idea?
Furthermore, the word 'should' implies necessity. (e.g.
"Im not sure whether I should do it") Thus, it sounds like you are posing a moral dilemma. If we are discussing right vs wrong on a particular subject, I'm uncertain what Scripture you are wanting to discuss about such a matter, or rather, what sin are you referring to concerning what you "should" do?